13th Juror Podcast

Sandra Birchmore: The Defense Rests | Matthew Farwell Trial

What if the evidence prosecutors say proves murder could have another explanation?
After weeks of testimony in the federal trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, the defense has rested. And its final witnesses presented a very different interpretation of Sandra Birchmore's death.
In this final full-length installment of our Sandra Birchmore trial coverage, we're breaking down the defense's case—and the testimony that could shape how jurors view the evidence.
From Sandra's mental health history and the original suicide determination to disputed medical findings, DNA evidence, and a digital timeline that has become central to the case, defense experts challenged some of the prosecution's most significant conclusions.
But under cross-examination, those experts faced difficult questions of their own.
Could Sandra's injuries really be explained by hanging? What does the cellphone evidence establish? And did investigators overlook important details—or interpret the evidence through the lens of a theory they were determined to prove?
We'll examine what the defense established, where its experts acknowledged uncertainty, and the evidence prosecutors say still points to homicide.
With both sides having presented their cases, the question now is whether the government has proven its allegations beyond a reasonable doubt.

This concludes our full-length trial coverage of the Sandra Birchmore case. Watch for continuing updates, including closing arguments, jury deliberations, and the verdict, on Court Report, right here on 13th Juror Podcast.

Y’all, there’s a reason we’re back for a second Court Report this week.
Juries return verdicts in the Andrew Griffin and Robert Kessler trials. We’ll hear what Stephanie Crone-Overholts’s family told the court at sentencing and why the judge had one last thing to say about that cheesesteak.
Then, an update on YNW Melly’s retrial and a look at Yella Beezy’s murder-for-hire trial, where a witness walks back his grand jury testimony. In Texas, a reported medical emergency leads to a murder indictment in the death of Mariah Little, a mother of three.
Plus, Naresh Bhatt takes the stand and gives a dramatically different account of what happened to Mamta. In the Cooper Ouellette trial, Sophie Ringquist’s texts help trace her ride home, and a witness fires back on cross-examination.
And a quick update on the Sandra Birchmore case as Matthew Farwell’s trial heads toward closing arguments. A new 13th Juror episode on the defense case is coming soon.

Court Report: A Chilling 911 Call, Courtroom Chaos & Major Trial Developments
Court Report is dropping EARLY this week, and there's a reason why. From shocking courtroom scenes to new evidence raising difficult questions, the first few days of November have already delivered some major developments.
In Ohio, Ashley Morgan is accused of murdering her boyfriend, Sean Reagan, and claiming self-defense. But what does the 911 call she made immediately after the shooting actually reveal? Brandi obtained the recording herself, and some of Ashley's statements raise questions that deserve a closer look.
In California, the sentencing of Larry Millete for the murder of his missing wife, Maya Millete, takes an emotional and chaotic turn as her family continues demanding answers.
Meanwhile, a mother in Oklahoma receives seven consecutive life sentences in a deeply disturbing child abuse case, and the long-awaited murder trial involving the son of TikTok personality Mama Tot faces an unexpected setback.
Plus, major developments involving Lindsay Clancy, Lori Vallow Daybell, Alex Murdaugh, and the murder trial of Robert Kessler.
And the week is far from over.
Another Court Report is coming later this week, along with a new episode of 13th Juror Podcast covering the latest developments in the federal murder trial of Matthew Farwell in the death of Sandra Birchmore.
The prosecution says. The defense says. But it's the jurors who have the final say.

Court Report | October 29, 2026
A woman calls 911 and admits she just shot her boyfriend. But what she says happened in the moments before she pulled the trigger raises questions about whether this was murder—or self-defense.
Meanwhile, a courtroom bombshell in the Lindsay Clancy case has two attorneys telling very different stories about what she allegedly revealed before the deaths of her three children.
A missing woman is reportedly found alive after more than two years. But just when her family thinks they might finally have answers, the story takes an unexpected turn.
A notorious serial killer is back in the headlines nearly four decades after his execution. And a Florida murder trial has barely begun, but what's happening inside that courtroom is almost impossible to believe.
This week on Court Report, we're following major developments in cases across the country, including a long-awaited verdict, a high-profile sentencing, and new trials with some fascinating evidence.
It's another packed week inside America's courtrooms.

Sandra Birchmore: The Final Witnesses | Part 2
What if the evidence that could change everything had been there from the very beginning?
As prosecutors wrap up their case against former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell, some of the most compelling testimony is still to come.
A medical examiner faces questions about a decision she made years earlier. An expert points to details that may tell an entirely different story. And when Matthew's own twin brother takes the stand, jurors hear about private conversations that raise even more questions.
But perhaps the most chilling testimony comes from the prosecution's final witness, who reconstructs the last recorded moments of activity on Sandra Birchmore's phone.
And the timeline is difficult to ignore.
With the prosecution's case complete, the question now is whether the defense can cast reasonable doubt on the story jurors have just heard.
This is Part 2 of our ongoing coverage of the Sandra Birchmore murder trial.
Matthew Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
This episode is sponsored by Primal Queen. Our listeners get a FREE MONTH of Primal Queen plus FOUR FREE GIFTS at https://PrimalQueen.com/JUROR. #ad
#zennipartner Use code PODCAST15 to get 15% OFF your first order, plus free shipping on all US orders over sixty five dollars at zenni.com/podcast