She's My Cherry Pie

Today’s guests are Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty, the stars of the Broadway musical “Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).” The show is a joyful, funny, and heartwarming story about chance encounters, unlikely connections, and one unforgettable day in New York City.
Christiani and Sam join host Jessie Sheehan to talk about their journeys to Broadway, what it’s like to carry an entire show as a two-person cast, and why “Two Strangers” has been described as a love letter to NYC. They also dive into the role cake plays in the show (yes, there is a real cake), the production’s partnership with Magnolia Bakery, and their personal dessert favorites—from red velvet cake to banana pudding to caterpillar cakes. 
"Two Strangers" audio clip courtesy of "Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)"
Order The Cake Issue
Pre-order our Galentine’s Day Issue
Bombesquad Bazaar tickets here
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here
Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, tickets to upcoming events, and more.
More on Christiani: Instagram
More on Sam: Instagram
More on “Two Strangers”: Instagram
Get tickets to the show
More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook

We’re kicking off our 2026 season with Justine Doiron, the beloved creator behind Justine Snacks. Justine is a cook, recipe developer, and the author of “Justine Cooks,” a New York Times bestselling cookbook.
Justine joins host Jessie Sheehan to talk about the path that led to her creative career, her childhood baking hobby, how she made her own wedding cakes, and her early days on TikTok. 
Then, Justine dives into her “obsessive” chocolate chip cookie behavior and the four recipes she developed for her book, specifically her Tall Rye Guy recipe. She explains how analyzing ingredient ratios changed the way she thinks about texture, spread, and flavor; why ratios matter more than technique; and why she believes cookies are best eaten warm and slightly underbaked.
Click here for Justine’s Tall Rye Guy Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe. 
Order The Cake Issue
Pre-order our Galentine’s Day Issue
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here
Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, tickets to upcoming events, and more. 
More on Justine: Instagram, website, “Justine Cooks” cookbook
More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook

We’re celebrating 2025 by re-airing our top episode of the year—host Jessie Sheehan’s interview with Nicola Lamb! Nicola is a London-based pastry chef and the author of “Sift: The Elements of Great Baking.” She has a pop-up bakery, Lark, and writes the popular Substack newsletter Kitchen Projects.
Nicola joined Jessie earlier this year for a deep dive into one of the world’s most loved pastries: the croissant. She talks about the complexities of adapting her recipe for home bakers after years of producing 10,000 croissants a week in a professional bakery. The duo get deliciously nerdy about technique—from lamination to honeycomb structure—and what it really takes to perfect this baked good at home. Nicola also opens up about her winding culinary path, from being “the office cake lady” to honing her craft at Dominique Ansel’s famed NYC bakery.
For Nicola’s croissant recipe, check out her book, “Sift.”
Click here for Nicola’s French Toast Cinnamon Buns recipe. 
Thank you to Diamond Nuts & California Prunes for their support. 
Order The Cake Issue
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here
Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, show transcripts, and tickets to upcoming events.
More on Nicola: Instagram, Substack, “Sift” cookbook
More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook

Today’s guest is Skye McAlpine. Skye is a food writer, cookbook author, and stylist based in Venice, Italy. She’s the author of several cookbooks, including “A Table in Venice,” “A Table for Friends,” “A Table Full of Love,” and her latest, “The Christmas Companion.” Skye also writes a monthly recipe column for The Sunday Times, contributes to publications like Vogue, Vanity Fair, and The Guardian, runs a Substack newsletter called The Dolce Vita Diaries, and is the founder of Skye McAlpine Tavola, a tableware and homewares brand.
Skye joins host Jessie Sheehan to talk about her life and career—from moving to Venice as a child and growing up between British and Italian Christmas traditions, to discovering her love of cooking and entertaining at university with nothing more than a toaster oven, to teaching herself how to cook and turning a food blog into a book deal. Then, Skye guides Jessie through her Chocolate and Chestnut Yule Log from “The Christmas Companion.” It’s a whimsical, showstopping holiday dessert made with a light chocolate sponge, chestnut cream filling, bittersweet ganache, and meringue mushrooms. 
Click here for Skye’s Chocolate and Chestnut Yule Log recipe.
Thank you to Diamond Nuts and California Prunes for their support. 
Order The Cake Issue
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here
Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, show transcripts, and tickets to upcoming events.
More on Skye: Instagram, “The Christmas Companion” book
More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook

Today’s guest is Carla Hall. Carla is a chef, cookbook author, TV personality, and all-around culinary force whose career has taken her from the runways of Paris to the sets of “Top Chef,” “The Chew,” and more. She’s the star and executive producer of the Emmy Award–winning series “Chasing Flavor,” a co-mentor on the new show, “Next Level Baker,” and the author of several books, including “Carla Hall’s Soul Food” and two children’s books, “Carla Hall and the Christmas Cornbread” and “Carla and the Tin Can Cake Party.”
Carla joins host Jessie Sheehan to talk about her life and career—from her childhood memories of her grandmother’s five-flavor pound cake, to the years she spent in Paris as a model discovering her love for cooking, to the moment “Top Chef” changed everything. Then, Carla walks Jessie through her Gingerbread Cake With Snow Sugar, a deeply spiced, ultra-moist loaf that uses the reverse-creaming method for a very tender crumb. She explains why hot water is the secret ingredient, how to make “snow sugar” that won’t melt into the cake, and why “sawing” is the only proper way to slice a loaf cake.
Click here for Carla’s Gingerbread Cake with Snow Sugar recipe.
Thank you to Diamond Nuts, California Prunes, and King Arthur Baking for their support. 
Order The Cake Issue
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here
Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, show transcripts, and tickets to upcoming events.
More on Carla: Instagram, website
More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook